Details
-
Task
-
Status: In Review (View Workflow)
-
Critical
-
Resolution: Unresolved
Description
my_vsnprintf() is used internally in the server as a portable printf replacement. And it's also exported to plugins as a service.
It supports a subset of printf formats and three extensions:
- %`s means that a string should be quoted like an `identifier`
- %b means that it's a binary string, not zero-terminated; printing won't stop at \0, so one should always specify the field width (like %.100b)
- %M is used in error messages and prints the integer (errno) and the corresponding strerror() for it
- %T takes string and print it like %s but if the string should be truncated puts "..." at the end
gcc knows printf formats and check whether actual arguments match the format string and issue a warning if they don't. Unfortunately there seems to be no easy way to teach gcc our extensions, so for now we have to disable printf format checks.
An better approach would be to use gcc compatible format extensions, like Linux kernel does. We should migrate to a different syntax for our extensions
- %sQ to mean "print as an identifier"
- %sB to mean "print a binary string"
- %iE to mean "print an errno"
- %sT to put a "..." as truncation indicator
It'll also need %sS as a synonym for %s as a form of escaping. In case someone needs to print a string, followed by T — using %sT will not do it anymore, so %sST can be used instead.
Old formats can still be supported or they can be removed. The major version of the service should be increased either way to signal an incompatible change (different semantics for, e.g., %sT).
All error messages and all usages of my_vsnprintf should be changed to use the new syntax. One way to do it is to disable old syntax conditonally, only in debug builds. All gcc printf format checks should be enabled.
Attachments
Issue Links
- relates to
-
MDEV-19784 C++11 protectors for my_error
- In Review
-
MDEV-35460 Phase out integer typedefs and macros in favor of C/C++ Standard ones
- Open
-
MDEV-22545 my_vsnprintf behaves not as in C standard
- Closed
1.
|
my_snprintf fixes for 10.5+ | In Review | Brandon Nesterenko | |
2.
|
my_snprintf fixes for 10.6+ | Closed | Daniel Black | |
3.
|
my_snprintf fixes for 10.11+ | Closed | Daniel Black | |
4.
|
my_snprintf fixes for 11.2+ | Closed | Daniel Black | |
5.
|
my_snprintf fixes for 11.4+ | Closed | Andrew Hutchings | |
6.
|
my_snprintf fixes for 11.5+: missing LEX_STRING::str calls in my_snprintf uses | Closed | Daniel Black | |
7.
|
Add printf format for GTID | Open | Unassigned | |
8.
|
Correction for table->space_id in dict_load_tablespace() was mistakenly applied on an earlier branch | In Testing | Unassigned |