Details
-
Bug
-
Status: Closed (View Workflow)
-
Major
-
Resolution: Fixed
-
10.1.14, 5.5(EOL), 10.0(EOL), 10.1(EOL), 10.2(EOL)
-
CentOS 6.8
Description
Hi,
The result of the ST_Centroid method does not seems correct.
For the same request:
SELECT AsText(ST_Centroid(ST_GeomFromText(' POLYGON((-122.8684759 49.2713048,-122.8804596 49.2712636,-122.880427 49.270522,-122.8932944 49.2704508,-122.893126 49.266063,-122.893084 49.2588789,-122.8927188 49.2458679,-122.892531 49.23803,-122.890696 49.236328,-122.8894146 49.2357782,-122.888219 49.236069,-122.886576 49.235914,-122.885352 49.235414,-122.8825066 49.2348937,-122.881285 49.234713,-122.8800524 49.2336459,-122.87881 49.23341,-122.877351 49.232865,-122.8763438 49.2318128,-122.875165 49.231153,-122.8750964 49.2305225,-122.876444 49.229864,-122.876627 49.2289017,-122.8764138 49.2282525,-122.8763938 49.2251511,-122.8755999 49.2253018,-122.8731537 49.2253684,-122.8727568 49.2453868,-122.8727889 49.245848,-122.8694309 49.2487784,-122.8690339 49.2493276,-122.868712 49.263537,-122.8684759 49.2713048)) '))) |
I get the following results:
- On MySQL v5.7.14: POINT(-122.88103164136591 49.25294096399097)
- On MariaDB v10.1.14: POINT(-122.88026060000001 49.24220679375)
The MySQL result seems to be the good one.
You can find attached a screenshot of the concrete case, as displayed in my application.
Sorry if the bug has been already opened, I didn't found any issue about this subject.
Attachments
Activity
| Field | Original Value | New Value |
|---|---|---|
| Description |
Hi,
The result of the {{ST_Centroid}} method does not seems correct. For the same request: {{SELECT AsText(ST_Centroid(ST_GeomFromText(' POLYGON((-122.8684759 49.2713048,-122.8804596 49.2712636,-122.880427 49.270522,-122.8932944 49.2704508,-122.893126 49.266063,-122.893084 49.2588789,-122.8927188 49.2458679,-122.892531 49.23803,-122.890696 49.236328,-122.8894146 49.2357782,-122.888219 49.236069,-122.886576 49.235914,-122.885352 49.235414,-122.8825066 49.2348937,-122.881285 49.234713,-122.8800524 49.2336459,-122.87881 49.23341,-122.877351 49.232865,-122.8763438 49.2318128,-122.875165 49.231153,-122.8750964 49.2305225,-122.876444 49.229864,-122.876627 49.2289017,-122.8764138 49.2282525,-122.8763938 49.2251511,-122.8755999 49.2253018,-122.8731537 49.2253684,-122.8727568 49.2453868,-122.8727889 49.245848,-122.8694309 49.2487784,-122.8690339 49.2493276,-122.868712 49.263537,-122.8684759 49.2713048)) ')))}} I get the following results: * On MySQL v5.7.14: {{POINT(-122.88103164136591 49.25294096399097)}} * On MariaDB v10.1.14: {{POINT(-122.88026060000001 49.24220679375)}} The MySQL result seems to be the good one. You can find attached a screenshot of the concrete case, as displayed in my application. Sorry if the bug has been already opened, I didn't found any issue about this subject. |
Hi,
The result of the {code:sql}ST_Centroid{code} method does not seems correct. For the same request: {{SELECT AsText(ST_Centroid(ST_GeomFromText(' POLYGON((-122.8684759 49.2713048,-122.8804596 49.2712636,-122.880427 49.270522,-122.8932944 49.2704508,-122.893126 49.266063,-122.893084 49.2588789,-122.8927188 49.2458679,-122.892531 49.23803,-122.890696 49.236328,-122.8894146 49.2357782,-122.888219 49.236069,-122.886576 49.235914,-122.885352 49.235414,-122.8825066 49.2348937,-122.881285 49.234713,-122.8800524 49.2336459,-122.87881 49.23341,-122.877351 49.232865,-122.8763438 49.2318128,-122.875165 49.231153,-122.8750964 49.2305225,-122.876444 49.229864,-122.876627 49.2289017,-122.8764138 49.2282525,-122.8763938 49.2251511,-122.8755999 49.2253018,-122.8731537 49.2253684,-122.8727568 49.2453868,-122.8727889 49.245848,-122.8694309 49.2487784,-122.8690339 49.2493276,-122.868712 49.263537,-122.8684759 49.2713048)) ')))}} I get the following results: * On MySQL v5.7.14: {{POINT(-122.88103164136591 49.25294096399097)}} * On MariaDB v10.1.14: {{POINT(-122.88026060000001 49.24220679375)}} The MySQL result seems to be the good one. You can find attached a screenshot of the concrete case, as displayed in my application. Sorry if the bug has been already opened, I didn't found any issue about this subject. |
| Description |
Hi,
The result of the {code:sql}ST_Centroid{code} method does not seems correct. For the same request: {{SELECT AsText(ST_Centroid(ST_GeomFromText(' POLYGON((-122.8684759 49.2713048,-122.8804596 49.2712636,-122.880427 49.270522,-122.8932944 49.2704508,-122.893126 49.266063,-122.893084 49.2588789,-122.8927188 49.2458679,-122.892531 49.23803,-122.890696 49.236328,-122.8894146 49.2357782,-122.888219 49.236069,-122.886576 49.235914,-122.885352 49.235414,-122.8825066 49.2348937,-122.881285 49.234713,-122.8800524 49.2336459,-122.87881 49.23341,-122.877351 49.232865,-122.8763438 49.2318128,-122.875165 49.231153,-122.8750964 49.2305225,-122.876444 49.229864,-122.876627 49.2289017,-122.8764138 49.2282525,-122.8763938 49.2251511,-122.8755999 49.2253018,-122.8731537 49.2253684,-122.8727568 49.2453868,-122.8727889 49.245848,-122.8694309 49.2487784,-122.8690339 49.2493276,-122.868712 49.263537,-122.8684759 49.2713048)) ')))}} I get the following results: * On MySQL v5.7.14: {{POINT(-122.88103164136591 49.25294096399097)}} * On MariaDB v10.1.14: {{POINT(-122.88026060000001 49.24220679375)}} The MySQL result seems to be the good one. You can find attached a screenshot of the concrete case, as displayed in my application. Sorry if the bug has been already opened, I didn't found any issue about this subject. |
Hi,
The result of the {{ST_Centroid}} method does not seems correct. For the same request: {code:sql} SELECT AsText(ST_Centroid(ST_GeomFromText(' POLYGON((-122.8684759 49.2713048,-122.8804596 49.2712636,-122.880427 49.270522,-122.8932944 49.2704508,-122.893126 49.266063,-122.893084 49.2588789,-122.8927188 49.2458679,-122.892531 49.23803,-122.890696 49.236328,-122.8894146 49.2357782,-122.888219 49.236069,-122.886576 49.235914,-122.885352 49.235414,-122.8825066 49.2348937,-122.881285 49.234713,-122.8800524 49.2336459,-122.87881 49.23341,-122.877351 49.232865,-122.8763438 49.2318128,-122.875165 49.231153,-122.8750964 49.2305225,-122.876444 49.229864,-122.876627 49.2289017,-122.8764138 49.2282525,-122.8763938 49.2251511,-122.8755999 49.2253018,-122.8731537 49.2253684,-122.8727568 49.2453868,-122.8727889 49.245848,-122.8694309 49.2487784,-122.8690339 49.2493276,-122.868712 49.263537,-122.8684759 49.2713048)) '))) {code} I get the following results: * On MySQL v5.7.14: {{POINT(-122.88103164136591 49.25294096399097)}} * On MariaDB v10.1.14: {{POINT(-122.88026060000001 49.24220679375)}} The MySQL result seems to be the good one. You can find attached a screenshot of the concrete case, as displayed in my application. Sorry if the bug has been already opened, I didn't found any issue about this subject. |
| Status | Open [ 1 ] | Confirmed [ 10101 ] |
| Attachment | mdev12915.png [ 43692 ] | |
| Fix Version/s | 10.0 [ 16000 ] | |
| Fix Version/s | 10.1 [ 16100 ] | |
| Fix Version/s | 10.2 [ 14601 ] | |
| Affects Version/s | 5.5 [ 15800 ] | |
| Affects Version/s | 10.0 [ 16000 ] | |
| Affects Version/s | 10.1 [ 16100 ] | |
| Affects Version/s | 10.2 [ 14601 ] | |
| Assignee | Alexey Botchkov [ holyfoot ] | |
| Labels | upstream-fixed |
| Status | Confirmed [ 10101 ] | In Progress [ 3 ] |
| issue.field.resolutiondate | 2017-07-25 12:18:14.0 | 2017-07-25 12:18:14.349 |
| Fix Version/s | 10.0.31 [ 22501 ] | |
| Fix Version/s | 10.2 [ 14601 ] | |
| Fix Version/s | 10.0 [ 16000 ] | |
| Fix Version/s | 10.1 [ 16100 ] | |
| Resolution | Fixed [ 1 ] | |
| Status | In Progress [ 3 ] | Closed [ 6 ] |
| Workflow | MariaDB v3 [ 80955 ] | MariaDB v4 [ 152226 ] |